(WBFF) — Luigi Mangione’s attorneys are pursuing a defense strategy that could reduce his state charge from murder to manslaughter, potentially cutting his prison time from life to a maximum of 25 years.
Two noted Baltimore defense attorneys, Steven Silverman and Warren Brown, reviewed the latest developments in the case and said the approach appears to center on a claim that Mangione was suffering from severe mental and emotional impairment at the time of the killing.
“It sounds like they’re going with the federal version of the insanity plea,” Silverman said.
Brown described the argument in blunt terms: “You got me, I was out of my mind…extreme emotionally disturbed.”
ALSO READ | Latest Luigi Mangione hearing shrouded in secrecy as judge shuts out press and public
Mangione, a Towson native from a prominent Maryland family and the 2016 valedictorian of the Gilman School in Baltimore City, is accused of murdering UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson in New York.
A judge on Wednesday said Mangione’s lawyers will argue that he was in the throes of “extreme emotional disturbance” and experienced a “profound loss of self-control” when he gunned down Thompson in December 2024.
Silverman said the strategy may be central to Mangione’s chances in the case. “His only hope of seeing the light of day is to enter this kind of plea,” he said.
Silverman also said the defense was foreseeable given the evidence. “You knew this was coming down the pike because the murder is on video,” he said.
Brown said the case could hinge on competing expert testimony. “It’ll end up being a battle of the doctors. He’ll have the way with all the money and the like to get some of the best doctors to spin that thing that he was so emotionally disturbed. That this is really not a case of murder, but more of manslaughter,” Brown said.
ALSO READ | Judge allows gun, notebook evidence in Luigi Mangione New York murder trial
Silverman said the defense could succeed if even one juror is persuaded. “All they need is one of these jurors, one out of 12, to say, I kind of think this guy’s a hero. I don’t agree with murdering people on the street, but I’m going to give him a pass. I’m gonna vote that he was insane at the time of the murder, and it only takes one to hang a jury,” he said.
Brown said the legal system recognizes limits on culpability when someone cannot control their actions. “In our jurisprudence, we try not to penalize individuals who act in such a fashion that they’re unable to control themselves. In Maryland, we refer to it as not criminally responsible,” he said.
Mangione faces life in prison if convicted of murder in the state case, or a maximum of 25 years if the charge is reduced to manslaughter.
Follow FOX45 reporter Keith Daniels on X and Facebook. Send tips to Kdaniels@sbgtv.com.
Local Story
